Chapter 32: Your Only Purpose Is to Surrender Your Land
"Your Majesty, the Han Dynasty cannot afford this war."
Zhang Liang spoke with earnest, painstaking advice. He believed that the national policy and ancestral teachings should not be fundamentally established based merely on a few words from Lu Xuan. Doing so would not only harm the present generation but would also jeopardize those to come.
Admittedly, after listening to Lu Xuan, his own blood had stirred; he felt that it was indeed right to strike hard against foreign tribes. But that was idealism. The reality was cruel: if the Han Dynasty were to follow such a path, there would inevitably be only one outcome—repeating the tragic fate of the Qin Dynasty.
"I know we cannot afford it, but Lu Xuan claims he can lead the Han Dynasty into a golden age and possesses weapons such as cannons. Why can we not fight?" Liu Bang stared at Zhang Liang and continued, "Furthermore, what Lu Xuan spoke of are events that occurred in the original trajectory of history. Even without Lu Xuan coming to the Han Dynasty, I would have eventually issued the national policy of 'never seeking peace through marriage, never paying tribute, the Emperor guarding the border, and the monarch dying for the state.' Although I do not know how long our dynasty will last, did you notice the ethnic designation on Lu Xuan's identification?"
"Han!"
"Lu Xuan's ethnicity is 'Han.' This signifies a profound connection to our dynasty, proving that the Han has become the symbol of the central plains' dominant people. It also proves that our dynasty endured for a long time and that the national policy I will issue in the future is correct—it did not lead to the Han Dynasty’s collapse like the Qin. If the Han did not fall due to military action in the original history, how can we speak of destruction now, especially with Lu Xuan's help?"
Liu Bang spoke with majestic ambition. He was truly moved and inspired by Lu Xuan’s words.
Zhang Liang hesitated for a long time after hearing this. Finally, he said, "But we do not have much time left, Your Majesty. We cannot obtain enough useful information from Lu Xuan within our limited time. The Xiongnu have invaded, and this will consume a great deal of time. We and Your Majesty will be occupied with managing the Xiongnu affairs; how could we possibly find the time to continue asking Lu Xuan about the future?"
"Moreover, I once said that the most important information to obtain from a person of the future is the national policies worth learning from throughout history, the tactical advancements born of changing times, and methods for dealing with foreign tribes. Forgive my rudeness, Your Majesty, but a month has passed, and not only have we failed to gain useful information on these three points, but everything we have learned has been limited to palace matters—such as the Crown Prince, the Empress's illness, and the future rebellion of the Fourth Prince. There is also the matter of Han Xin and the vassal kings."
"If we want to resolve these issues within three months, we will likely need to question Lu Xuan repeatedly. Where will there be time to ask about military tactics, sound policies, or methods for handling foreign tribes?"
Zhang Liang said much, but his ultimate goal remained to persuade Liu Bang not to heed Lu Xuan's words to wage all-out, continuous war against the Xiongnu—and perhaps even to shift from defense to offense.
Liu Bang's thinking, however, was simple. He believed in Lu Xuan's abilities and felt that with Lu Xuan's assistance, the Han Dynasty was capable of constantly attacking foreign tribes. Zhang Liang felt that Liu Bang's thinking was naive; Lu Xuan was indeed capable, but the Emperor was not asking about the truly useful things, focusing instead only on his own princes.
A rift had formed between them.
Liu Bang was a man who could listen to reason. He remained silent for a long while before saying, "It is my mistake. Very well, let us wait and see if the King of Han, Xin, can hold Mayi."
Ultimately, Liu Bang decided not to issue the national policy mentioned by Lu Xuan for the time being.
Time passed, and soon, news arrived from Mayi.
The Xiongnu's Chanyu Modu led an army of two hundred thousand to attack Mayi. The King of Han, Xin, was unable to withstand the assault and defected to the Xiongnu! The fifty thousand troops commanded by the King of Han merged with the two hundred thousand Xiongnu soldiers and began marching toward Taiyuan!
Upon learning this news, the entire Han court was shaken. Emperor Liu Bang ordered all civil and military officials to gather at Changle Palace to discuss state affairs.
"I placed high hopes on the King of Han, yet he has betrayed me and fled. Alas, how painful!" In the court, Emperor Liu Bang, wearing his crown, spoke with visible heartache, slamming his hand against the dragon desk beside him.
He remembered clearly: at the beginning of this year, believing the King of Han to be strong and brave, he had ordered the King of Han to relocate to the region north of Taiyuan Commandery to guard against the Xiongnu, establishing his capital at Jinyang. At that time, among all the vassal kings, he had trusted him the most, precisely because the King of Han had not secretly recruited troops like the others.
Back then, the King of Han had petitioned: "My fief borders the frontier, and the Xiongnu invade frequently. Jinyang is too far from the border; I request permission to move my capital to Mayi." He had agreed, and the King of Han moved his capital there.
And now, after he had trusted him so deeply, he had betrayed the Han to surrender to the Xiongnu?
"Your Majesty," an official said, "Chanyu Modu leads two hundred thousand troops. Mayi, which the King of Han defended, was the capital of the state of Han, with over fifty thousand soldiers—mostly men of Han. The two forces have merged and are now marching toward Taiyuan!"
Hearing this, Liu Bang’s heart sank further. This was not good news. Just like the Qin Dynasty, the early Han faced a problem it could not resolve: many commoners and soldiers did not identify as people of Han; they still considered themselves people of Chu, Han, Qin, or Qi. This meant they viewed the people of the Central Plains no differently than they viewed foreign tribes. For instance, the people of the state of Han regarded the people of Chu and the Xiongnu as the same—foreigners, not of their own kind.
This was not an isolated phenomenon; such sentiments remained widespread throughout the Han territory. Thus, the merger of the Xiongnu’s two hundred thousand and the King of Han’s fifty thousand formed a massive force.
A difficult problem now lay before him: should he lead the campaign against the Xiongnu himself, or send Han Xin? In terms of military command, he was naturally no match for Han Xin, and he could trust Han Xin's strategic competence completely. But if Han Xin were to hold such a massive force, what if he turned against him? He had worked so hard to stabilize Han Xin, after all.
As his thoughts churned, Liu Bang heard various voices rising from below as officials offered their ideas.
"I believe we should mobilize the troops of all the vassal states to strike back at the Xiongnu!"
"No, the dynasty is newly established; how can we engage in such grand warfare? The imperial army alone is sufficient to defeat the Xiongnu."
"The King of Side-by-Side Rank has distinguished military achievements and unparalleled command ability; I believe he should lead the army."
Suggestions poured in like a tide. Liu Bang knitted his brows tightly. Being an emperor was difficult, especially when facing such choices. Every suggestion had its merits, but also its drawbacks and risks. He had to choose the most correct path; otherwise, he could not bear the consequences of failure.
At this moment, Han Xin stepped out.
He stated clearly, "Your Majesty, the King of Han has surrendered to the Xiongnu, leading fifty thousand men to defect. He has failed to repay the imperial grace of his title. This shows... that Your Majesty has been too kind to your meritorious subjects."
Having finished, he turned to face the officials and the founding nobles, his tone deepening: "I am willing to lead the army, but as the dynasty is newly founded, our grain supplies are insufficient. My proposal is to ask the meritorious officials to voluntarily donate their land to the common people. Those who refuse will be considered accomplices of the King of Han."
Two simple sentences left the ministers pale, their hands and feet cold. The King of Side-by-Side Rank was seizing this opportunity to strike at the founding nobility.
Liu Bang, sitting above, immediately understood Han Xin's intent. Han Xin had previously proposed three measures against the founding nobles to ensure their safety and his own peace of mind, but Liu Bang had found them too ruthless and had not immediately agreed. Now, Han Xin was using this opportunity to push one of them through.
Asking the nobles to divide their land for the people was a way to strengthen the Han state while ensuring sufficient grain for the front lines. After all, commoners were reluctant to hand over their own grain to the imperial government. Why? Because if they handed it over, what would they eat the coming year? But if they had enough land, it would be different. If they had land to farm and would not starve, what was the harm in handing over grain to the state to fight foreign enemies? The commoners would more directly see the danger posed by the Xiongnu.
At the same time, this was Han Xin’s way of "self-soiling." Once this was done, the nobles—their interests harmed—would inevitably view Han Xin as an enemy, which would make Liu Bang willing to let him lead the army.
As Liu Bang pondered, some officials in the court began to object.
"We are here to discuss how to repel the Xiongnu. What does this have to do with the land of the meritorious officials? I do not understand why the King of Side-by-Side Rank brings this up."
"Indeed, the urgent matter at hand is to discuss tactics against the Xiongnu."
"The Xiongnu are aggressive, and with the help of the Mayi army, we haven't even settled on a strategy, yet we are discussing other things?"
Faced with their words, Han Xin smiled faintly.
"I have my own tactics to repel the Xiongnu. You do not need to deliberate. Moreover, the tactics you discuss carry little meaning in my eyes."
"In the face of this Xiongnu invasion, your only role is to donate your land to the commoners, making them willing to contribute grain to the court. As for tactics and methods of battle, that is not for you to think about, nor do you have the ability to conceive them. Is my meaning clear?"