Chapter 33: The Rolling Heads of Meritorious Officials
Page 1 of 3
Han Xin’s words left everyone’s faces even more livid. We knew you were formidable when it came to commanding troops, but was there really any need to look down on all of us so openly?
With so many of us here, were we truly inferior to you alone?
Yet no one refuted Han Xin. In terms of status, Han Xin was now the King Who Stood Shoulder to Shoulder with the Emperor, his rank equal to that of the Son of Heaven. In terms of military ability, no one could compare with him. As for the Xiongnu invasion, everyone could rest completely assured if Han Xin were sent to deal with it.
But the King Who Stood Shoulder to Shoulder with the Emperor could go if he wished.
Why did he have to slash at the interests of the meritorious officials before setting out to repel the Xiongnu?
Some of the more astute ministers had already begun to perceive the truth. They realized that Han Xin was doing this to set the Emperor’s mind at ease.
In former times, Wang Jian had led six hundred thousand troops against Chu, and had likewise used the tactic of deliberately tarnishing his own reputation to prevent Ying Zheng from growing suspicious of him. Han Xin’s circumstances were clearly different. The King of Han’s achievements, status, and wealth had already reached their limit. If he demanded money or land, it would only seem contrived. Only by setting himself against all the ministers could he both reassure the Son of Heaven and secure considerable benefits for the Han dynasty.
Those who understood this no longer said anything. Combined with the rumors that had circulated earlier—namely, that His Majesty intended to bestow iron warrants exempting their holders from death—they had already realized that Han Xin would become the blade used to harvest the meritorious officials, a sharp edge wielded by the Emperor to avoid the fate described in the old saying: “When the cunning hare is dead, the hound is cooked; when the birds are gone, the fine bow is put away.”
At such a time, speaking out would mean making an enemy not only of the King Who Stood Shoulder to Shoulder with the Emperor, but of the Emperor himself.
Their fate would hardly be pleasant.
“Since the King Who Stands Shoulder to Shoulder with the Emperor has made up his mind, let it be so.”
“Brothers, do not blame the King for this. It is all for the sake of giving our Han dynasty enough strength to repel the Xiongnu.”
Liu Bang spoke at that moment, playing the benevolent peacemaker.
Han Xin played the stern villain, while he himself played the forgiving hero.
It felt rather comfortable.
“As for the campaign against the Xiongnu, and the matter of the meritorious officials offering up their lands for the war, the King Who Stands Shoulder to Shoulder with the Emperor shall handle everything.”
“Then it is settled.”
Liu Bang’s voice rang out once more, and he slowly rose to his feet.
He was entirely at ease entrusting the campaign against the Xiongnu to Han Xin.
Han Xin had also chosen to tarnish his own reputation and set himself against all the ministers.
Thus, Liu Bang’s wariness toward him vanished.
He had been worrying about how to face the Xiongnu invasion, yet the problem had been resolved with unexpected ease.
“All of this is Lu Xuan’s doing.”
Back in Linhua Hall, Liu Bang sat alone upon the Dragon Throne and murmured to himself. Then he shook his head and sighed.
What a pity. What a pity.
They were simply too afraid that Lu Xuan might reach for power. They could only kill him two months from now.
“Soon. Soon. Only two months remain.”
“The matter of the Xiongnu has delayed things for quite some time. In reality, I may still be able to ask Lu Xuan questions for another month.”
Liu Bang felt irritated. Being Emperor was not as free and easy as people imagined. Although his ministers shared the burden of handling the various affairs of state, he still had to devote a great deal of time to them each day. And even if the Xiongnu campaign had been handed over to Han Xin, he still had to worry constantly about the situation at the front.
Han Xin was indeed invincible in battle.
But who could guarantee that he would win every time?
Or, to put it another way, if Han Xin truly had never known defeat, why had he not declared himself king in the past and divided the realm among himself, Liu Bang, and Xiang Yu? Perhaps the answer lay in the fact that Han Xin, deep down, lacked a certain measure of confidence as well.
As time passed, Liu Bang did not go to see Lu Xuan that day. Burdened by many worries, he went to sleep.
Several more days passed, and Liu Bang remained busy with the affairs of state.
Page 2 of 3
The court had seemed somewhat turbulent of late. The King Who Stood Shoulder to Shoulder with the Emperor, Han Xin, had ordered the meritorious officials to volunteer their lands, stirring up considerable unrest. Not every minister was willing to comply.
“I have followed His Majesty ever since the uprising began. I shed blood to establish this Han realm! These lands are what I deserve. Why should I surrender them?”
“What a joke. They made Han Xin the King Who Stands Shoulder to Shoulder with the Emperor, and now he truly thinks himself the equal of the Son of Heaven? I shall take this matter up with His Majesty personally!”
“I refuse to give up a single acre. Let us see what Han Xin can do to me!”
Confronted with these defiant men, Han Xin found himself at a loss. He did not know what to do, and he was unwilling to seek help from anyone.
At first, Han Xin had intended to purge these meritorious officials outright.
But they had committed no crime. They merely refused to surrender their lands. How could he punish them?
Han Xin had his pride and did not wish to ask anyone for assistance. Yet he could not think of the best solution. At that moment, Chen Ping arrived and offered him a suggestion.
“Does the King Who Stands Shoulder to Shoulder with the Emperor know of the matters concerning Wen Zhong and Wu Qi?”
Wen Zhong and Wu Qi!
Han Xin’s expression changed. Chen Ping was suggesting that, in order to eliminate the meritorious officials, he find a way to fabricate charges against them.
At the end of the Spring and Autumn period, King Goujian of Yue was defeated by King Fuchai of Wu. He endured humiliation, slept on brushwood, tasted gall, and plotted the restoration of his kingdom.
The minister Wen Zhong devised strategies for him and formulated the Seven Methods for Conquering Wu. These enabled Goujian to destroy Wu, avenge himself, and become one of the hegemons of the Spring and Autumn period.
Yet after Wu was destroyed, Goujian’s attitude changed.
Fan Li knew that Goujian was a man with whom one could share hardship but not prosperity. He chose to withdraw once his success was achieved and wrote to Wen Zhong, urging him to leave as well.
Wen Zhong did not heed his advice. Before long, Goujian believed slanderous rumors and grew suspicious that Wen Zhong harbored disloyal intentions. He bestowed a sword upon Wen Zhong and said, “You taught me seven methods for conquering Wu. I used three of them to destroy Wu, while the other four remain with you. You may use them on my behalf to test the former kings.”
Left with no alternative, Wen Zhong took his own life.
In this manner, Goujian used trumped-up charges to eliminate Wen Zhong, his greatest meritorious servant. Perhaps he had feared that the official’s power had grown too great and sought to consolidate his own rule.
Wu Qi’s fate was even more tragic.
At the beginning of the Warring States period, Wu Qi carried out reforms in Chu.
King Dao of Chu placed great trust in him, and Wu Qi implemented a series of reforms: clarifying the laws, reviewing official orders, reducing the number of officials, and abolishing stipends for distant members of the royal clan. As a result, Chu’s national strength increased rapidly.
But these reforms harmed the interests of Chu’s old aristocracy.
After King Dao of Chu died, the old nobles seized the opportunity to launch a rebellion and attack Wu Qi.
They fabricated charges against him and made him the chief culprit responsible for destroying Chu’s established order.
Wu Qi was ultimately shot to death in the mourning hall of King Dao of Chu, and the reforms collapsed with his death.
Han Xin was tormented by indecision. Should he truly use such methods?
His character was complex and multifaceted, but he also cherished the bonds of brotherhood forged through shared life and death. Many of the meritorious officials he was supposed to deal with were brothers who had once stood beside him. To resort to such schemes against them—would that not be too cruel?
“What should I do?”
Han Xin was capable when it came to commanding armies, but he had little experience with matters such as these. He had originally believed that helping His Majesty harvest the wealth of the meritorious officials, distribute it among the common people, and restore the strength of the Han dynasty would be easy. Yet once he actually began, he discovered that it was extremely troublesome.
He had thought that one imperial decree and one blade would settle everything.
Instead, every step proved extraordinarily difficult.
Han Xin’s thoughts were in turmoil. The court was already organizing and mobilizing the army. Within two or three days, a force of three hundred thousand would be ready, and he would lead it to Taiyuan to repel the Xiongnu.
Before that, however, he had to deal with this matter properly. He had to succeed in tarnishing his own reputation, otherwise the Emperor would never allow him to command the army.
Page 3 of 3
He was also eager to tarnish his own reputation, for only then could he earn the Emperor’s trust.
He firmly believed that once he had successfully harvested the wealth of the meritorious officials, made them turn against him, and then driven back the Xiongnu, the Son of Heaven, Liu Bang, would no longer harbor any suspicion of him.
“Enough. Kill them.”
Han Xin shook his head, his heart growing colder.
From the perspective of the state, these meritorious officials had indeed rendered great service and deserved wealth and honor. But now that the Xiongnu had invaded and the nation was in peril, why were they unwilling to surrender a little land?
Since they refused to offer it, then their estates would be confiscated!
Han Xin acted with thunderous decisiveness. With Chen Ping’s assistance, he fabricated charges and sent twelve meritorious officials to prison. He had originally intended to confiscate all their estates.
Then Liu Bang, playing the merciful hero, stepped forward and ordered Han Xin to spare them. It would be enough for them merely to surrender their lands.
Thus, they kept their lives.
And because of this, Han Xin became the sworn enemy of every minister in the court.
Once all of this had been accomplished, Liu Bang finally set his mind at ease regarding Han Xin. Han Xin, too, felt reassured and led the army off to war against the Xiongnu.
The Son of Heaven, Liu Bang, personally accompanied Han Xin to the outskirts of Chang’an. Watching the mighty army gradually disappear into the distance, he said slowly to Zhang Liang at his side, “It has been a long time since I last saw Lu Xuan. Let us go and visit him.”
Liu Bang had been extremely busy during this period. Aside from his own governmental duties and the matter of the Xiongnu, he had been even more concerned with Han Xin’s methods of dealing with the meritorious officials.
They were simply too ruthless.
At the slightest disagreement, Han Xin threatened to confiscate entire estates.
If this continued, would it not lead to trouble?
Anyone capable of standing in the imperial court could see that Han Xin’s treatment of the meritorious officials had certainly been sanctioned by the Son of Heaven himself. It was only for various reasons that they dared not resent Liu Bang directly. They could only vent their anger upon Han Xin. By now, they were probably all thinking of ways to kill him.
If matters continued this way, the imperial treasury would indeed grow fuller, and the common people would gain more farmland.
But with so many ministers and all their tangled relationships gathered together, could Han Xin—and the Son of Heaven himself—truly withstand the consequences?
What if a major upheaval actually occurred, with the meritorious officials joining forces as one?
The more Liu Bang thought about it, the more worried he became.
Concerned, Liu Bang wanted to ask Lu Xuan whether anything similar had ever occurred in history. He took Zhang Liang with him and went to Lu Xuan’s small residence. As it happened, Lu Xuan had finished answering questions for the day and had been scheduled to move into the courtyard.
After arriving at Lu Xuan’s place and exchanging a few words, Liu Bang voiced the worry in his heart.
“Master Lu, have there ever been instances in history in which meritorious officials were purged on a massive scale? What sort of circumstances and consequences would such a thing bring about?”
Liu Bang’s question caused Lu Xuan to pause.
A massive purge of meritorious officials?
Of course, there had been many such incidents throughout history.
But whenever anyone heard those words, the first person they would inevitably think of was Zhu Yuanzhang, who had ruthlessly purged the founding meritorious officials during the early Ming dynasty.
Why was Uncle Ji asking this?
Was he referring to the Hu Weiyong case, or the Li Shanchang case?
It should not be the Lan Yu case. After all, that case occurred only after Crown Prince Zhu Biao’s death. Based on the information Crown Prince Zhu Biao had learned earlier, there was a very good chance that he was still alive.
After thinking for a moment, Lu Xuan said, “There were indeed several cases in history involving the large-scale purging of meritorious officials. But in later generations, whenever people speak of such purges, the first thing that comes to mind is the reign of our dynasty’s founding emperor.”
“He killed so many meritorious officials that blood ran like rivers and severed heads rolled across the ground. A single case could claim the lives of more than thirty thousand people! Many of the founding meritorious officials were killed.”