Chapter 35: You Will Drive Me to Death with Your Insolence
At this point, Lu Xuan sighed and said leisurely, "This case has its pros and cons. The benefit is that it eliminated the potential threat of prime ministerial power to imperial authority, greatly enhanced the supreme status of the throne, achieved a high degree of centralization, ensured that all political decrees emanated from the Emperor, and laid a foundation for the stability of the political system."
"But there are also many drawbacks."
"How could a normal case implicate so many people? During the escalation of the case, many innocent officials and civilians were dragged in. To achieve the goal of purging 'partisans,' His Majesty encouraged officials to denounce one another, leading to many being incriminated due to personal grudges or groundless suspicions. This resulted in a large number of unjust cases, and many talented officials were killed, bringing catastrophe to their families. At the same time, such large-scale executions caused everyone in the imperial court to fear for their lives. To protect themselves, officials dared not offer frank remonstrance or take proactive action, leading to a repressive political atmosphere. Such extreme measures destroyed the basic trust between ruler and subject, disrupted the normal political order and administrative efficiency, and had long-term negative effects on the healthy development of the bureaucracy. Although imperial power was strengthened in the short term, in the long run, excessive centralization burdened the Emperor with too many administrative duties, making it difficult to attend to every matter. Moreover, when an Emperor lacks ability or neglects governance, it easily leads to a power vacuum, burying hidden dangers for issues such as the usurpation of power by eunuchs."
"Once I reach the capital, I will certainly explain the consequences of this matter to His Majesty, so that at the very least, many talented and innocent officials will not perish in vain."
Lu Xuan felt deep regret over this matter. Just imagine, the ancients who could enter officialdom all possessed extraordinary abilities; perhaps if they had lived, they could have made the Great Ming even better.
Perhaps among their descendants, there might have been pillars of state like Zhang Juzheng who could have extended the longevity of the Great Ming dynasty.
"More than thirty thousand people killed..."
Liu Bang tremblingly raised his own hands. He looked at his large, dark, and weathered hands, which had seen so much hardship and war. Would these very hands, in the future, bloodily execute so many ministers?
And all for the sake of centralizing power?
Would Chancellor Xiao He ultimately die by his own hand?
Would he execute Xiao He just to abolish the position of Chancellor?
"No, His Majesty is not that kind of person. He would never abolish the prime ministerial power, let alone kill his Chancellor, just for the sake of centralization." Liu Bang, never believing he would do such a thing in the future, immediately retorted.
Hearing this, Lu Xuan said indifferently, "Why is it impossible?"
"People change. Suppose you were the Emperor: you struggled from nothing to build an empire, yet you handed the power over to a Chancellor to manage. Wouldn't you feel a void in your heart?"
"After finally becoming an Emperor, you wouldn't have had your fill of the addiction to power."
"Furthermore, a normal person could not do such things, but an Emperor is not a normal person. A qualified Emperor has no personal feelings. For the sake of power and the stability of the dynasty, every Emperor is eventually polished into a cruel, cold political machine."
"How can you guarantee that the Emperor of today won't be changed by the future?"
Lu Xuan's words left Liu Bang silent.
Indeed.
He currently believes he could never do such a thing.
But what about the future?
Can he guarantee that he will never do it?
As he gradually grasps the power of the Son of Heaven, his own temperament will be stained by the touch of power, and his original inner emotions will gradually grow cold as the years pass and power struggles ensue. Can he guarantee he will hold onto his original intent?
Han Xin was merely proud and arrogant, holding heavy troops, yet even without any signs of rebellion, Liu Bang had already developed a murderous intent.
In his eyes, Xiao He is closer to him than Han Xin, but when the day comes that the prime ministerial power becomes too great and threatens the throne, can he guarantee he won't strike?
Inside Lu Xuan's room, Zhang Liang remained silent, not daring to utter a single word.
His head was bowed to the extreme.
He wished that His Majesty would never notice him.
He never expected to hear such things; that in the future, His Majesty would be so heartless as to kill Chancellor Xiao!!
Sure enough, when the birds are gone, the bow is put away; when the cunning rabbits are dead, the hounds are boiled—the ancients did not deceive me!
And what about himself?
Was he on the list of those to be purged?
Zhang Liang's heart trembled constantly, filled with absolute terror. He had only wanted to ask about the consequences of the mass execution of meritorious officials in later dynasties, never expecting to accidentally learn of the future Emperor's methods from Lu Xuan.
Liu Bang naturally noticed Zhang Liang's emotional fluctuations, and his heart was filled with complexity. Could it be that from this day on, the Marquis of Liu would no longer trust him?
Is he a cold-blooded, ruthless, and tyrannical monarch?
"Do these founding meritorious officials not have items like iron certificates of immunity from death?"
To soothe Zhang Liang's emotions, Liu Bang couldn't help but ask. Lu Xuan smiled, "Uncle Ji, you shouldn't take these iron certificates of immunity too seriously. It looks like this thing truly has the power to exempt one from death, but the final interpretation remains with the Emperor."
"If the Emperor wants a person to die, a small piece of iron is useless."
"Let's put it this way: because this case dragged on, another founding minister—the kind whose merits were enough to rank in the top three—had three such certificates, and wasn't he still executed? His entire clan was even wiped out!"
Lu Xuan felt that this so-called iron certificate of immunity was sometimes a joke.
In the third year of Hongwu, Zhu Yuanzhang enfeoffed his meritorious officials. Li Shanchang, due to his immense contributions, was granted the titles of Founding Assistant, Promoter of Integrity and Righteousness, Civil Official, Specially Promoted Grand Master of the Palace, Pillar of State, Grand Tutor, and Left Chancellor of the Secretariat. He was enfeoffed as the Duke of Korea, with an annual stipend of four thousand piculs, hereditary for his descendants, and was bestowed an iron certificate.
Of these three certificates, two could exempt Li Shanchang himself from the death penalty, and the third could exempt his son.
However, in the twenty-third year of Hongwu, Li Shanchang was ordered to commit suicide by Zhu Yuanzhang due to his implication in the Hu Weiyong case, and over seventy members of his family were executed.
Despite the iron certificates, they could not save his life.
The iron certificate of immunity was not omnipotent. Its final interpretation belonged to the Emperor. Once the Emperor determined that someone's crimes threatened the foundation of his rule, the certificate could provide no shelter.
"In short, these certificates are of little use."
!!!
Zhang Liang's heart skipped a beat.
A founding minister, merits ranking in the top three.
It was widely acknowledged that in the process of establishing the Han Dynasty, he, Xiao He, and Han Xin ranked in the top three. So, who else could this executed and clan-exterminated person be but himself?
As for the three certificates, he guessed that the future Emperor would bestow three upon him? It was highly likely; after all, having made so many contributions, the future Emperor might truly grant him three.
"Lu Xuan, that courtyard has been cleaned up. Old Fang and I will go check it again, then come back to pick you up."
Liu Bang was no longer in the mood to listen. His mind was in chaos. A moment ago it was just about Xiao He, but now, as he listened, it seemed he would also kill Zhang Liang. Could he really be that cruel?
Liu Bang and Zhang Liang left the side hall of Lin Hua Palace immediately. Upon returning, Liu Bang looked at Zhang Liang, "Marquis of Liu, do you think what Lu Xuan said is true?"
"I do not believe this will happen in the future. I am not a cruel and heartless monarch."
Who would have thought that Zhang Liang would fall to his knees with a thud.
"Your Majesty, your servant understands. Your servant understands everything."
"Liang knows that when he becomes useless, he will choose to hang himself."
Liu Bang's expression stiffened, and he explained, "I truly will not do such things in the future..."
"Your Majesty, if a ruler treats his subjects like brothers, the subjects treat the ruler like their heart and soul; if the ruler treats his subjects like dogs and horses, the subjects treat the ruler like a stranger."
"If the ruler orders the subject to die, how can the subject linger on?"
Zhang Liang's heart was filled with melancholy. He had indeed been a failure his whole life. When young, he wanted to restore the State of Korea, but failed no matter what he did. After achieving fame and success, he always wanted to retire to the mountains and forests to have a peaceful end, but now he learned that he was very likely to be implicated and killed in the future.
My life has been like walking on thin ice.
"Alas, I am truly not that kind of person. How could I kill meritorious officials at will, especially the Marquis of Liu?" Liu Bang scrambled in a panic. He felt that what Lu Xuan said was indeed a possibility, but he still did not believe that he would do such a thing in the future.
But Zhang Liang might not believe it.
How was he to explain this?
"Your Majesty, rest assured, I will not tell Xiao He about this," Zhang Liang said.
Liu Bang's head was spinning. Normally, this matter shouldn't be told to Xiao He, but he had never intended to kill Xiao He. If he knew the future and didn't clarify things with Xiao He, what would happen when Xiao He eventually found out?
Furthermore, apart from him, the only people in contact with Lu Xuan were Zhang Liang and Xiao He. If he deliberately concealed it, how could he continue to question Lu Xuan? What if Lu Xuan suddenly brought it up—how would Xiao He view him?
"I will have Xiao He come over now and explain this matter clearly."
"I will absolutely not kill you."
Liu Bang sent someone to summon Xiao He. Xiao He arrived in a hurry, and Liu Bang explained the whole situation in detail.
Hearing this, Xiao He bowed respectfully: "If it is for Your Majesty to abolish the chancellery and centralize power, your servant is willing to die."
"Are you all trying to be the death of me? I said I would not kill you!!"
Liu Bang felt as if his chest was going to explode. How was he supposed to explain this clearly?